Best of all Time
Go undefeated during a season
100 ✓ January 11th, 2011
We Idolize You
Get an overall Approval Rating of 95, after one season
75 ✓ January 11th, 2011
Gameday Guru
Complete a head to head match on Xbox LIVE
50 ✓ January 11th, 2011
We Love You
Get an overall Approval Rating of 90, after one season
50 ✓ January 11th, 2011
One for the Mantle
Win the Coach of the Year award, after one season
50 ✓ January 11th, 2011
You Arrived
Win your first Super Bowl ring
30 ✓ January 11th, 2011
We Like You
Get an overall Approval Rating of 85, after one season
25 ✓ January 11th, 2011
Xs and Os Guy
Create at least 25 custom plays
20 ✓ March 17th, 2009
Drawing Some Plays in the Dirt
Create at least 10 custom plays
10 ✓ March 17th, 2009
Media Darling
Get your approval level with the media to 80, after one season
10 ✓ January 11th, 2011
One Big Happy Family
Get your approval level with your coaching staff to 80
10 ✓ January 11th, 2011
Best Ever
Win the Super Bowl 3 times with the same team
250 
Welcome to the Club
Win 100 games with a created coach
125 
Repeat Offender
Win back to back Super Bowls with one team
100 
🔐 A Cut Above
Get the highest overall approval Rating in the league, after one season
20 
Goal Oriented
Accomplish all of your Season Goals
15 
🔐 Nerves of Steel
Make 20 Defining Moments decisions with positive results
10 
Gold Miner
Find 90+ Potential Training Camp Invite
10 
Mr Popularity
Get your approval level with the fans to 80, after one season
10 
Teachers Pet
Get your approval level with your owner to 80, after one season
10 
Man of the People
Get your approval level with your team's players to 80, after one season
10 
I'm The Decider
Get 100 percent correct defining moments during a game day
10