1-2-3
Retire all 3 batters faced in an inning (Pro difficulty or higher).
10 ✓ May 6th, 2008
Frozen Rope
Get a line drive base hit using Right Stick Hitting (Pro difficulty or higher).
5 ✓ May 6th, 2008
Quality Start
Have your starting pitcher give up 3 or fewer runs in 6+ innings of work (Pro difficulty or higher).
5 ✓ May 6th, 2008
Keep it Down
Complete a 9-inning game without giving up a home run (Pro difficulty or higher).
5 ✓ May 6th, 2008
A Day To Remember
Throw a no-hitter using any number of pitchers (minimum 9 innings, Pro difficulty or higher).
100 
Advanced Mind, Advanced Pleasure
Complete 10 games using advanced controls.
50 
Earn 100 Cards
Unlock 100 different types of cards.
50 
Strikeout the Side
Strikeout all 3 batters faced in an inning (Pro difficulty or higher).
50 
Legendary
Win a 9-inning game on Legend difficulty.
50 
Card Master
Win a Card Battle match on Xbox LIVE.
50 
You're Not So Tough
Top 'em: In a ranked match on Xbox LIVE, beat an opponent who has unlocked 'A Day to Remember'.
50 
What Makes YOU So Special?
Top 'em: In a ranked match on Xbox LIVE, beat an opponent who has unlocked a Top 'em achievement.
50 
Earn a Team
Unlock all the cards for a team in card series 1.
30 
Double Triple
Hit two triples in one game (Pro difficulty or higher).
30 
Domination
Win at least 105 games in one season (min 20 games played)
30 
Win 20 Online
Win 20 ranked matches on Xbox LIVE.
30 
Buy a Pack
Use your duplicate cards to buy a new pack of cards.
20 
He's Got a Gun!
Throw out a runner at homeplate from the outfield using Right Stick Throwing.
20 
The Train's Comin' Through
Score a run after plowing over the catcher at homeplate (Pro difficulty or higher).
20 
De-Railed
Successfully prevent a runner from plowing over your catcher and scoring (Pro difficulty or higher).
20 
Triple Double
Turn 3 double plays in one game (Pro difficulty or higher).
20 
Goliath
Hit 5 home runs in one game (Pro difficulty or higher).
20 
Star-Studded
In franchise, have 3 or more players make the All-Star Team (min 15 games played).
20 
Makin' a Splash
In franchise, have a rookie earn the Rookie of the Year award (min 20 games played).
20 
Contender
In franchise, have your team make the playoffs (min 20 games played).
20 
Slugger
Win a Strikes Only match on Xbox LIVE.
20 
Cards Shmards
Top 'em: In a ranked match on Xbox LIVE, beat an opponent who has unlocked 'Earn 100 Cards'.
20 
David vs. Goliath
Top 'em: In a ranked match on Xbox LIVE, beat an opponent who has unlocked 'Goliath'.
20 
Another Level
Top 'em: In a ranked match on Xbox LIVE, beat an opponent who has unlocked 'Legendary'.
20 
Live Wire
Top 'em: In a ranked match on Xbox LIVE, beat an opponent who has unlocked 'Win 20 Online'.
20 
Fantasy Cards
Create a complete card team.
10 
Catch 'em Nappin
Successfully bunt for a hit (Pro difficulty or higher).
10 
Red-Handed
Throw out a runner attempting to steal a base (Pro difficulty or higher).
10 
Eagle Eye
Get a Base on Balls (Pro difficulty or higher).
10 
Glove of Gold
In franchise, have a player win the Player's Choice Best Fielder award (min 20 games played).
10 
Platinum Bat
In franchise, have a player win the Player's Choice Best Hitting award (min. 20 games played).
10 
Layer Cake
In franchise, win a game at each minor league level (A, AA, and AAA).
10 
The Brink of Stardom
In franchise, have a player win the Minor League Player of the Year award.
10 
I'm a Winner!
Win a ranked match on Xbox LIVE.
10 
League Participation
Play a game in a league or tournament on Xbox LIVE.
10 
Control Artist
Throw a Total Control Pitch with superb execution.
5 
Hold!
Get credit for a hold (Pro difficulty or higher).
5 
Save!
Get credit for a save (min 3 batters faced, Pro difficulty or higher).
5 
Skillz
Make a spectacular defensive play (Pro difficulty or higher).
5 
What's Your Fantasy?
Complete at least 25 rounds of a fantasy draft in franchise mode.
5