Have Mercy!
Win every Story Mode game using the mercy rule
75 
Cyclone
Hit for the cycle with a single player
45 
Love of the Game
Defeat The Bullies in Story Mode
45 
They Call Me Bonehead Fred
Score the winning run in the bottom of the final inning with two outs and two runners left on base
40 
Like Lou
Hit a grand slam
35 
Run! Run! Run!
Hit an in-the-park homer
35 
Like Nolan
Hold your opponents to zero runs (5-inning game)
35 
Grand Theft
Steal home
35 
Triple!
Hit for a triple
30 
Triple Play!
Get three runners out in a single play
30 
Speed Demon
Steal second and third base with the same player in the same inning
30 
Blast Those Quads
Get four or more hits with one player in a single game
30 
Batting Around
The whole team gets a swing during a single inning
25 
Like Joe
Win in the final inning while things are looking down (5-inning game)
25 
Double to Nuttin'
Keep your opponent from scoring a run after leading off with a double or a triple
25 
3 Up, 3 Down
Strike out three batters in one inning
20 
Double Play!
Get two runners out in a single play
20 
Like Bill
Win a game with a walk off home run
20 
Double!
Hit for a double
20 
Greased Lightning
Get a single on a bunt attempt
20 
Back Against the Wall
Hit a home run with two strikes and zero balls
20 
Decked Out
Got all the gear in Story Mode
20 
Back to Back, Jack!
Hit back to back out of the park home runs
20 
Slugger Star
Tony joins your team in Story Mode
20 
Twin All-Stars
Sid & Ash join your team in Story Mode
20 
Backyard Powerhouse
Pablo joins your team in Story Mode
20 
The Cannon
Keisha joins your team in Story Mode
20 
Upper Classman
Jorge joins your team in Story Mode
20 
Rocket Launch
Vicki joins your team in Story Mode
20 
Mac Attack
Joey joins your team in Story Mode
20 
Mathlete
Dmitri joins your team in Story Mode
20 
Great Balls of Fire!
Earn a double or better with the Fire Bat
15 
Like Cy
Win a game without changing pitchers
15 
Ice Catch!
Freeze a fielder using The Icicle
15 
Out of This World
Hit a home run off a Meteor Ball
10 
There is No Spoon
Successfully hit a Mirage Ball
10 
Houston, We Have a Problem
Strike out a batter using the Rocket Ball
10 
Ribby
Congratulations on your first RBI!
10 
Savin' the Day!
Change pitchers before the final inning and win the game
10 
First W
Congratulations on your first win!
10 
No Quarter Given
Earn a win through the mercy rule
10 
Going... Going...
Hit one out of the park
10 
Nice Pitch, K?
Strike out a batter
5 
Patience is a Virtue
Get a walk while at bat
5 
Tick Tock
Get blowed up real good by a Ticking Time Ball
5